• Vragen? Wacht niet langer op de antwoorden! Login of Registreer en plaats jouw vraag! Wij zullen je vragen z.s.m. beantwoorden.

Cartago small radiator's Guide

cartago2202

New member
Cartago small radiator's Guide​



Hello, and welcome to my first guide.

In this guide I want to help you a bit in the selection of the correct size radiator.
It is the biggest test I've done so far.



Many of us are in range of suitable radiators not sure.
The possibilities of installation in many cases are quite limited.
So often the question arises of how powerful a radiator must be in order to cool my system.
The mass of different radiator sizes, it is easy to make radical error, and equip their system with undersized radiators.
The possibility that money is useless to throw out the window of course given in the form of too much radiator area.
Of course the second option is the lesser evil, but it would be better to invest the money elsewhere.



So, how big a radiator do?



I've asked this question of course frequently, so I got the idea to make a very big guide about the performance of the radiators in various sizes.
For this guide I were a total of nine radiators available, would be in the detail:

Phobya G-Changer Ver 120th 1.2 Black
Phobya G-Changer 140
Phobya G-Changer 240 Ver. 1.2 Black
Phobya G-Changer 280
Phobya G-Changer 360 Ver. 1.2 Black
Phobya G-Changer 420
Phobya G-Changer 480 Ver. 1.2 Black
Phobya G-Changer 560
And finally, a NOVA 1080 Phobya Xtreme radiator




Given the enormous range of different manufacturers and radiators, I have decided
to make all tests with the manufacturer Phobya radiators. Especially since this shall carry out any relevant variables in its range,
and you get a good impression of the scalability of a series.



This guide is designed in three basic different sections.

To a throttled with default settings for the processor and GPU, going strong with overclocked processor, at a quite high voltage and ultimate benefit, with OC and fans.

One of the requirements of this guideline was that no component can reach 80 degrees. However, should it happen, the test is aborted and not classified as passed,
since the sense of a water cooling system would be a mistake now complete.

The purpose of a water cooling system is, in my eyes to keep the components as much as possible to cool and the low background noise.
Therefore, the test run with fans throttled.


The system:



For this guide I've used quite a common system with base 1156, it asks a good compromise between power and heat generation.
The newer socket 1155 system, as regards the heat, much less problematic
if you do not play with all high voltages.
And the base 1366 in this review, in turn, would exclude virtually all smaller radiators from the outset,
that the system produces much more heat.


The test system in detail:


Motherboard: Asus Maximus II Formula
Processor: Intel Core i7 860 stock and with 4 Ghz @ 1,4 V
Video Card: AMD ATI Radeon HD6950 @ 6970 with 1.175 V
Memory: 8GB Corair Vengeance CL9
[H] PSU: [/B] be quite! Dark Power Pro 850W P9
HDD: 500GB Samsung F3


Water cooling in detail:


CPU Cooler: Alpha HF14 Yellowstone cooper edition
GPU cooler: Koolance VID697
pump Phobya DCP 12 400
Conditions: Alphacool Cape Cyclone HF38 150 V.2
: 16/10 Alphacool Screw Cooper
DFM: AC DFM HighFlow
control : Alphacool Heatmaster
temperature sensors: 2xPhobya female / male screw-on ¼ and Conditions
tube 16/10 Masterkleer
4 quick couplers Koolance VLN3


As a fan came to use:


Phobya Nano G-12 PWM Silent redled
Phobya Nano G-14 Black Silent Edition
Phobya G-18 Silent redled


Flow rates on individual radiators I have deliberately avoided that in this combination
more than 150 Radiator Lph no matter what was on the line.

Water temperature was measured in degrees Celsius with a tolerance of 1 ° sensors.

Would be tested with Prime95 and rthdribl.exe.

Idle does not mean that the system is not used in front of him is special, it is for mail, surfing YouTube, etc. used.

The values ​​of the three sensors I've summarized and represented an average temperature in diagrams.




Here are the values:


Stock:


nonocstock3nqe.png


dnonocstockqufj.png



Stock @ 50%


nonocstock50tudx.png


dnonocstock50snur.png



OC:


oc100eu4i.png


doc100qndr.png



OC @ 50%


oc50mnnv.png


doc50iu8m.png





One must still bear in mind that these tests at one, rather low room temperature have been carried out.

To be precise, the temperatures were as follows:

In stock tests 21 ° -22 °
OC tests at 23.5 ° -25 °




The fan speeds were as follows:


Phobya Nano G-12 PWM Silent redled
At 100% = 1460 rpm
At 50% = 720 rpm


Phobya Nano G-14 Black Silent Edition
At 100% = 1160 rpm
At 50% = 600 rpm


Phobya G-18 Silent redled
At 100% = 720 rpm
At 50% = 350 rpm





Well as you can see it, not all radiators have managed to keep the system cool enough.
Was it even without overclocking all the radiators have been able to cool the system, the picture changed even in the reduction of the speed.
Even with the reduced speed to 50% had to give up the 120s, 140s and 240s of the radiator.
Thus, they are not suitable alone to cool the system. The rest of the radiators is hereby no problems.



When overclocked system, things are even worse.
Since the values ​​are still acceptable even at idle, but that's changing, just as soon as the CPU is stressed.
If then there are the graphics card are claimed missing out gradually more radiators.


Only from the radiator 280, it is possible to cool the system enough.
Probably noticed with fan at 100% which is not very silent except for the Nova 180 with their fans, which are also at 100% yet pleasantly quiet.


If we reduce this still the speed is so slow very closely.
The test system is cooled only by four of the nine radiators sufficient.


And I saw quite a big surprise.
The 360 ​​is not able to cool the system and the mind at a room temperature of more than 25 °.
What comes next in the summer, when increases in some under the roof at room temperature over 30 °?
I am aware of the very few games that generate simulated load in real mode games,
but you should really, the room temperature can not ignore.




My conclusion, for this system, mind you , clearly missing here.
At least a 420 radiator or if space is not allowed in the housing, a 360-plus 120/140er radiators radiator is the minimum
what you need. You want an SLI / CF or maybe even cool with another component, one should consider the possibility of an external radiator installation into consideration.
Here's the radiator or Nova1080 Mora, with the possibility of installation of 180mm fans, a perfect and above all easy to implement alternative to the internal installation.
One must also realize my conclusion in relation to my system.
In systems, especially not overclocked, things look quite different.
Sufficient for this purpose, completely out of control in a 360 radiator to cool the system effectively and quietly.
Again, in a heavily overclocked so.1366 system with two or more graphics cards, I would definitely fall into a similar Nova1080 or radiator.



I hope this guide can help you a bit further and am of course open to ask the community to provide.




legend

T & C = Reservoir
DFM = flow meter
@ stock = default values ​​for the processor and graphics card HD6950
OC = system overclocked to 4GHz processor at 1.4 V, the HD6970 video card with BIOS
50% = rotate fan at half power
100% = rotate fan at full power
Lph = liters per hour


declaration to influence the flow of the cooling power:


There was in this comparison, the flow at all radiators over 150 liters per hour, the flow rate played no role.
However, with more restrictive coolers and weaker pump varies, of course, the influence of flow on the cooling performance.
In general, a flow is viewed by more than 60 liters per hour than the optimum. Bring a further increase in temperature usually no bigger profits with them.




For assistance with this guide, I would like to thank the following companies: Alphacool and Phobya thank you very much.
My thanks goes to the company: Asus Corsair PowerColor and be-quite! for their support.
 
Vergelijkbare onderwerpen
Onderwerp starter Titel Forum Reacties Datum
C [User-Review] Complete Set: Swiftech H2O-320 kit in Cartago's Edge Review. HighFlow Product Reviews 2
C What to bring 180mm atria (DS) or on Nova1080? Short test of Cartago's Review. HighFlow Product Reviews 1
C [User Review]ApogeeHD vs. RAYSTORM vs.Kryos vs. SupremeHF in Cartago´s Review HighFlow Product Reviews 0
C [User-Review]World´s First: the new XSPC Radiator EX 360 in Cartago´s Review HighFlow Product Reviews 2
C Cartago´s HD6970 water cooler Roundup HighFlow Product Reviews 0
C Cartago´s Quad-Radiator Roundup HighFlow Product Reviews 2
C [User-Review] Alphacool NexXxoS HD6970/6950-- GTX580/570 im Cartago´s Review HighFlow Product Reviews 1
C [User-Review] Phobya G-Silent 18 700rpm RedLed im Cartago´s Review HighFlow Product Reviews 3
C [User-Review]Alphacool Cape Fuzion Core 30 Acetal Black in Cartago´s Review HighFlow Product Reviews 3
C [User-Review] Alphacool CapeCora HF 1042 im Cartago´s Review HighFlow Product Reviews 1
C [User-Review] Alphacool VPP655 Single Edition pump im Cartago´s Review HighFlow Product Reviews 0
kier [GEVONDEN] Rode Mdpc sleeve small Gevonden 3
Brutus Project Small Box Gallery & Build Logs 0
P hardnekkig virus in omloop Win32/TrojanDownloader.Small.NFG trojan Hardware & Software 14
J Fans voor 360 radiator Overige Koeling 0
Jason Thermaltake Pacific CL360 Plus RGB Radiator HighFlow Product Suggesties en Nieuws 0
Jason Terug op voorraad: XSPC TX240 Ultrathin Radiator HighFlow Product Suggesties en Nieuws 2
Jason PrimoChill Rad Clean - Radiator Cleaning Treatment - Full Kit HighFlow Product Suggesties en Nieuws 0
Jason Thermaltake Pacific CL360 Plus RGB Radiator HighFlow Product Suggesties en Nieuws 0
Jason XSPC TX240 Ultrathin Radiator HighFlow Product Suggesties en Nieuws 0
Jason Magicool G2 Slim Radiator 16 FPI - 240mm & 360mm - White HighFlow Product Suggesties en Nieuws 0
M Welke pomp en welke radiator? Waterkoeling 2
Ruud Radiator gpu HighFlow Forum 1
J Lucht in radiator Waterkoeling 2
G [TKA-RAD] EKWB PE240 Radiator Verkocht 1
Hightower Ekwb radiator schroeven HighFlow Product Suggesties en Nieuws 1
Jaap 20cm radiator voor HAF miditower Advies Waterkoeling Setup 5
Demolisher Thermaltake Riing Plus 12 LED RGB Radiator Fan TT Premium Edition HighFlow Product Suggesties en Nieuws 4
Deathchant Nieuwe PC: radiator positionering en welke fans voor beste koeling en airflow? Hardware & Software 17
anub1s18 idee nodig voor kraan op een radiator te mounten voor drain Waterkoeling 5
K webshop toon radiator, radiator en radiator,...maar welke is beter ? Advies Waterkoeling Setup 3
S Advies nodig Radiator.. Waterkoeling 6
DBRichard [TKA-RAD] Coolgate G2 Radiator (10 FPI) 360mm Verkocht 2
C Inlet outlet radiator hw nemesis 360gts Waterkoeling 4
XenoMorpH [GEVONDEN]Dunne 360 Radiator Gevonden 4
T Goede 140mm LED fans voor Radiator Advies Waterkoeling Setup 0
P XSPC EX480 Quad Fan Radiator (White) HighFlow Product Suggesties en Nieuws 1
Bas9466 gezocht 480 mm x 60 mm radiator Gevonden 0
I Case opties voor grote radiator Cases en Modding 12
D Radiator keuze Define S Waterkoeling 9
volcom HW Labs GT Stealth 240 of Magicool slim 240 radiator Waterkoeling 0
S Template gaten 120mm voor radiator Cases en Modding 4
P Advies gevraagd voor keuze 420 radiator Waterkoeling 10
J Reservoir aan radiator monteren Waterkoeling 2
N Vraag plaatsing radiator Waterkoeling 3
D Thermaltake Core V1 fully customized with 200mm radiator and fully customized loop. Gallery & Build Logs 2
D Resorator 1 i.b genomen ...niet genoeg koeling...Radiator i.c.m. genoeg flow ??? Waterkoeling 1
sir serial [GEVONDEN] 240 mm dunne/slim radiator Gevonden 1
Michel EK-CoolStream PE radiator extenders Waterkoeling 4
T Welke fan voor radiator? Overige Koeling 15

Vergelijkbare onderwerpen

Bovenaan